Nanny vs. daycare · Seattle
A nanny costs about
$0
more a month than daycare — with every cost counted.
Nanny
Daycare
We assume 40 hours a week for the nanny. Daycare is a flat monthly tuition, so the hours only change the nanny’s cost.
Tap a row to drill in. Hit Edit to remove.
Fewest kids per teacher first.
Sources.
Nanny hourly rates: Care.com’s average nanny rate by state (the average starting rate nannies post on Care.com; as of October 2025). A second child adds roughly $2–$4/hour per Care.com; we use $3.
Daycare hourly rates: computed from Shortlist’s own source-verified provider prices — the median of each city’s published tuition, converted to an hourly rate using each provider’s published hours (see methodology). As of July 2026. Cities without enough source-verified prices (Kansas City, Charlotte) are not offered here rather than shown an estimate.
Employer tax estimates: IRS Publication 926, Household Employer’s Tax Guide and IRS Topic 756 (as of tax year 2025).
Backup care: emergency drop-in care market rates and Shortlist provider drop-in pricing (typically $1,000–$1,800/yr for 10 days of coverage; as of Q1 2026).
Center closure days, staff sick leave: Washington RCW 49.46.210 paid sick leave and Shortlist parent survey (n=124, 2025–2026).
Nanny replacement risk ($2,000/yr): agency placement fees plus 1–2 weeks of gap coverage, amortized over the 1.5–2 yr median nanny tenure (as of Q1 2026).
Socialization ($900/yr): typical Seattle music, gym, and playgroup class fees for one toddler when daycare peer time isn’t replacing them (as of Q1 2026).
Registration ($300) and supply fees ($400): Shortlist provider survey median, applied per child per year (as of Q1 2026). Actual fees vary by program.